Original Letter to Bishop Bambera

Posted On November 4, 2020

Original Letter to Bishop Bambera

MAY 03, 2019

March 20, 2019

Dear Bishop Bambera,

Since the recent scandal broke, your statements to date have not answered specific questions

regarding your involvement in the sex abuse scandal in the Diocese of Scranton.

One month after you became the Vicar of Clergy in 1995, Fr. Robert Gibson left a treatment

center and was assigned to St. Ignatius in Kingston, PA. You were involved in the investigation

of Fr. Gibson and did not report the abuse to authorities even though the protocol at the time

demanded you do so. Instead, you sent him to a parish where he finally left after he began

grooming another boy. The Diocese of Scranton has four complaints of sexual abuse regarding

Fr. Gibson.

Why didn’t you report Fr. Robert Gibson’s immoral and criminal behavior to the

authorities? Why was he sent to a parish after the diocesan investigation?

In November 1996 you were the Vicar of Clergy and supervised Fr. Al Liberatore. You wrote a

memo to Bishop Timlin expressing your concerns regarding Fr. Al Liberatore’s questionable

behavior with both a seminarian and the Director of Youth & Young Adult Retreats who was a

young man in his early 20s. At this time, Fr. Al Liberatore was the Director of Vocations for the

Diocese and was living at the St. Pius X Seminary.

After you wrote the memo to Bishop Timlin, were you concerned that Fr. Liberatore was

living with young men at the seminary? Why did you keep Fr. Liberatore in the position

of Vocations director, giving him access to young high school and college age men?

In February 1997 while you were the Formation Director and living at St. Pius X Seminary,

twenty male high school students were touring the seminary and through an open door, they

witnessed Fr. Liberatore giving a back massage to a seminarian.

In Spring 1997 while you were still the Vicar of Clergy and Formation Director at the seminary,

Fr. Liberatore was involved in an altercation with the Director of Youth & Young Adult Retreats.

This young man, the Director of Youth & Young Adult Retreats, later shared that he had been

sexually harassed by Fr. Liberatore. After the altercation that night, this young man woke up that

next morning in Fr. Liberatore’s room with Fr. Liberatore’s hand on the man’s genitals. You

never contacted or interviewed this young man. This young man who was in his early 20s was

serving as the Director of Youth for the diocese and was involved in the altercation.

You had already expressed concern about Fr. Liberatore’s behavior, so why didn’t you

speak to the young man? Had you heard about Fr. Liberatore’s sexual harassment of

young men?

After this altercation, Fr. Liberatore was then moved to St. Clare’s in Scranton, PA. Fr.

Liberatore went on to sexually abuse an altar boy between 1999 & 2004. He brought this boy to

New York City, consumed alcohol, and they spent the night in the City together.

Were you ignorant of Fr. Liberatore’s grooming behaviors and harassment?

After 1998 you moved into parish life. In 2003 Fr. Al Liberatore became a professor of theology

at the University of Scranton, and you joined the Board of Trustees for the University of

Scranton that same year.

Given your past knowledge of Fr. Liberatore’s prior “questionable behavior”, did you as a

board member at anytime raise concerns with the university? Was the University of

Scranton aware of Fr. Liberatore’s grooming behaviors and sexual harassment?

Fr. Jeffrey Paulish was reassigned fourteen times during his twenty-five years as a priest. Fr.

Paulish was granted four leaves of absence. Every assignment put him in direct contact with

children and altar servers. Fr. Paulish only stopped being a priest in the Diocese of Scranton

when he was found in a parked car with a minor engaging in oral sex in 2013.

Why was Fr. Paulish reassigned so many times and granted four leaves of absence?

Was he ever involved in inappropriate behavior with adults?

Each day you sit in authority over this diocese, and your decisions impact the safety and

spiritual life of our children. We are asking you to answer these specific questions.

Sincerely,

Paul and Kristen

Paul Ciaccia

Related Posts

Church sex abuse scandal prompts podcast

DALLAS, Pennsylvania — Paul and Kristen Ciaccia remember the news that sparked their anger. In 2013, they learned their sons had served as altar boys with a priest who had just been arrested on charges that he had oral sex with a minor. “That was the first ‘What?’...

Response from our Bishop

  MAY 03, 2019   OFr'ICE OF THE BISHOP   DIOCESE OF SCRANTON 300 WYOMING AVENIJE SCRANTON, PENNSYLVANIA 18503 -1279 April 3, 2019   Dear Mr. and Mrs. Ciaccia: Thank you for your recent letter. Please accept this letter in response. Your letter...